Source: The Scotsman, 21st April 1924
MILLER AND SMITH SCORE.
In the circumstances Aberdeen did well to win by 2-0, yet their victory might have been attained by a greater margin. Although they scored twice, their forwards were not very successful at goalmouth, but even so they were a much better combination than those of Kilmarnock, who could make nothing of the Aberdeen defence. The opening goal followed the missing of several chances, and fell to Miller after 25 minutes' play. Paton worked his way forward, and about ten yards from goal judiciously passed to the centre-forward who flashed the ball into the net with great speed. Previous to this, Miller had lost more than one opportunity, and the Kilmarnock goalkeeper had saved severaI from him, Grant, Smith, and Forbes, the efforts by Miller and Forbes being splendidly parried by J. Morton. The second goal was obtained close to the interval. Grant carried the along, and beating Gibson, lobbed it over to the left, Smith dashed in, and shot with force, the ball striking the Kilmarnock goalkeeper and glancing into the net. In the period the Kilmarnock forwards had been dangerous on several occasions, but except for two attempts - one by Borland and one by Gray - Blackwell was not seriously bested.KILMARNOCK WELL BEATEN.
Kilmarnock pressed in the opening stages of the second half, and Blackwell had twice to save from Borland, but with the visitors' extreme wingers preferring to shoot rather than cross the ball no great danger ensued to Blackwell's charge, and the defence was not seriously stretched. Gradually Aberdeen took the upper hand and even without Forbes their forward's repeatedly raided the opposing defence. Following Forsyth's injury, Smith went to left back, but before the finish he returned to the attack, taking up the inside left position, and Hutton exploited the one-back game. Forsyth, Smith and Grant all had good shots for Aberdeen, and Morton's goal had several narrow escapes. Miller hitting the post on one occasion. On the home side all the defence played to form, and in attack Smith, and Forbes were best, but despite the scoring of two goals, the line was not particularly effective in front of goal. Kilmarnock gave a most disappointing display, and were fortunate to escape a heavier defeat. J. Morton, if appearing to lack confidence, kept goal in good style. Gibson was the better back, but the middle division was weak, and in an attack that was always in the grip of the Aberdeen defence, Gray, Rattray, and Borland were best. There was an attendance about 10,000.Source: Press & Journal, 21st April 1924