Source: Aberdeen Daily Journal, 14th October 1907
A Brace for the A's.
Lochee United did not put up a strong opposition to the Aberdeen A at Pittodrie. There was only a fair attendance, due to the Lifeboat Demonstration, which started at the same time. The locals won the toss, and, in a twinkling, they were at Reilly, and but for the eagerness of the new centre a score should have resulted. All through, the A's pressed, but the ball could not pass the goalkeeper. Only once did Mutch have to handle a shot from Burns, who was the only forward on the visiting side to make ground. Collins, Aberdeen's new centre, shaped poorly in this half, which was just about finished when Edgar scored. In the second period the new, centre wakened up, and put in a few solo runs on his own, while he passed well out to his wings on occasion. The feature, however, was the fine work of the right wing, Macdonald and Simpson, whose work was really pretty to watch. For as effective as this pair were in making ground, the scoring came from the left, where Toman was also in fine trim, the first goal which he scored being a beauty. The second he took from a rebound off the goalkeeper, and though corners were abundant, the game finished 3-0 in favour of the A's.The Players.
Mutch had a holiday. For a first appearance R. G. Tait was a signal success at left-back, his kicking being neat and clean, while he has a fine turn of speed, and between him and Hannah there seemed a perfect understanding. There was very little to choose between the halves; they were all strong in their work, and kept the opposing forwards from being dangerous. The right wing gave a great exhibition, and the centre, who is only a lad of nineteen, could be made a player with judicious coaching and training. Edgar did some smart things, but was very careful of himself. Toman was better than we have yet seen him, and gives promise of being a fine wing player. Reilly saved his side from a double figure score, while the backs and halves had to put in a lot of telling work. The only forward we fancied was the centre, Burns, who has a fine command of the ball, and can shoot on the run. In fact, he has all the qualifications of a class centre.Source: Bon-Accord, 17th October 1907