Teams representing the Aberdeen and Banff clubs met at Pittodrie on Saturday in the first round of the Fleming Charity Shield. Being the close season, there was little enthusiasm in the game, and, consequently there was a very meagre up attendance, which numbered about 500. The weather, too, was against a large turnout, although it was on the tapis that Aberdeen were to have some new players on view. When the teams lined out the Pittodrie eleven included Colman, Hume, Davidson, H. Murray, and Soye, of last year's league eleven, and King, Macfarlane, Hay, and Edgar, of the A team, a new centre half and centre-forward (whose names were not die bulged to the press) making up the remainder of the eleven. The Banff team was composed of Paterson; Lyall, Torry; Grant, Bremner, Clark; Ellis, Paterson, Donald, Wood, Reid.
As to the game, and made the little comment opponent. The home club from the outset appeared to take the fixture as a Halliday one, but although the forwards - especially the right wing - showed tricky football, their shooting abilities were poor indeed. All credit must be given, however, to the visiting defence, Paterson, his backs, and Bremner footing in some sound work. Bert Murray was always dangerous when he got away, and Edgar, well plied with the ball, sent across some fine centres, which Newman had hard lines in not getting past the Banff goalkeeper on one or two occasions. The newcomers showed a fair idea of the game. Against an experienced defence the visiting forwards were of little account, and King had only two shots of a likely nature to dispose off in the first half. One of these was from a penalty taken by Bremner, who shot straight at the home goalkeeper, who cleared easily. At half-time neither team had scored.
As in the first half, heavy showers of sleet interrupted the play, and the Banff 11 against the breeze had the worst of matters, and this time to the extent of three goals. Bert Murray, after a minute's play, hooked in the sphere passed Paterson. After this the Wasps were almost continuously in the visitors' territory, and only the smart custodianship of Paterson kept down the score. He had, however, to acknowledge a second defeat from the Pittodrie centre, although all the credit for the goal is due Hay, whose shot the goalkeeper could not hold. On time Davidson made his team's total three, and a poor and uninteresting game ended Aberdeen 3 goals, Banff 0.
Source: Aberdeen Daily Journal, 9th May 1910