On resuming it was thought the visitors might show some improvement, and if they did it was scarcely noticeable. McNicoll at forward put on the third goal with a good shot which beat Davidson all the way. The visitors were still acting on the defensive, and seldom got up on the home goal. Twice McFarlane handled, but that was about all. It was no surprise when Low scored the fourth and McNicoll headed through number five. Nearing the close McAulay, who had been showing an improvement on recent form, got hurt and had to be carried off. It was a decided relief when the whistle sounded time up with the Aberdeen leading by 5-0.
Points from Pittodrie.
We are pleased to relate that Aberdeen are still among the "qualifiers," and trust they will be for some time. One thing is certain, and that is they have had two soft ties to begin with, and should be able to tackle something harder when needed without feeling unduly fagged. Saturday's game was a farce, pure and simple. It was amusing, but it was certainly not football. If Forres Mechanics can give Elgin City 8-2, then we are wondering what like the latter team is like. Davidson deserves a line to himself. He was the only man to show anything like play, and who really deserved his railway fare paid. We shall say nothing about the £30 guarantee. Louden, at centre half, was the only other man who could be relied upon, and he was hardly sure of his kick. We don't know what the backs had, but one thing they had not - an understanding. The right back had good style and sometimes a fairly decent kick. The Mechanics were very persevering and plodded on when all was lost, but they lacked style and finish and generally a good idea of the game to make themselves felt. McFarlane we cannot criticise, as he practically got nothing to do, while the same may be said of the backs. Low was the outstanding man in the middle line, with Halkett a good second. We are glad to notice a great improvement in Strang and trust that very soon he will be on a par with his partner. McNicol was easily the best man in the front rank needs to be kept at inside right as that seems to be his correct form. We hope McAulay will soon be back and that the reserves have done him good. Ellis is very eager, but his position is certainly not centre forward. One trial is enough to show that, as he did not seem to have anything but a crude idea of his place and duties. Ritchie will require to be superseded by Johnstone, as his displays lately have been exceedingly poor. A goal fell to Robertson, but that is not enough reason to keep him in the first eleven. Mr. Hood kept the game in band in a capable manner, but his position was a sinecure and easily held. We note a change in the home crowd's behaviour. It showed a bit of true sportsmanship on Saturday.
Source: Bon-Accord September 22, 1904
Source: Aberdeen Daily Journal, 19th September 1904