Source: Unknown, possibly The Scotsman 26-09-1905
ABERDEEN'S SECOND GOALThe game was stopped for a few seconds, and from a throw-up ward got the ball. He was blocked by Richmond, but got through, and passed the ball ahead. Lennie, dashing in from the left, completely beat Skene with a low, fast shot. Aided by the splendid work of the half backs, the Aberdeen forwards again burst through the amateurs' defence, Ward passing the ball in deadly fashion across the Queen's goal. Edgar and Lennie just failed to get their heads on the ball. Ward, Lennie, and Edgar were prominent in the Aberdeen attack, their footwork being really clever. Halkett next tried a shot at Skene, and the goalkeeper had great difficulty in holding the ball. Queen's were continuously hemmed into their own territory, their half-backs failing to hold the clever Aberdeen forwards, backed up by as they were by the steady play of Halkett, Strang, and W. Low. Play was stopped owing to an injury sustained by Edgar, who was carried off the field. When play was resumed, Ward was neatly stopped by Houston, who a minute later ran across to tackle Lennie on the run, and gave away a corner. The ball was sent away from Queen's quarters, but was immediately brought up by Hilton, whose tricky and resolute play caused Richmond much anxiety. A foul against the Queen's was placed short by Wilfred Low, and Davidson the Queen's outside left, was off with a clear field, when he was smartly brought up by Murray. Aberdeen returned to the attack, Ward's head being much in evidence in working forward passes from the half-backs. Murray again stopped the Queen's forwards in resolute style. Notwithstanding the fact that they were playing with only 10 men, Aberdeen had all the play so far as pressing was concerned. Queen's Park's display was certainly not worthy of their reputation, combination on their side being conspicuous by its absence. Edgar returned to the field and was loudly cheered. For the first time in 20 minutes Macfarlane got his hands on the ball, but there was half of field's length between him and the nearest "spider." Notwithstanding that they had the sun in their eyes, the Aberdeen half backs were playing an almost perfect game. Edgar working the ball to the penalty line, shot with terrific force, Skene getting his knuckles on the leather just on the bar. The ball skiffed across, and Skene again got his hands upon it, but in doing so collided with Hilton who was on the spot, and fell striking his face on the ground. Skene give away a corner, but the save was very skilfully effected. From the corner, well placed by Robertson, Queen's got the ball away, but immediately Ward returned with it. Tackled by Higgins, Ward trickily outwitted the back and drove hard at the net, the ball just grazing the upright. The Pittodrie forwards were again working their way westwards when the whistle blew for half-time with the score - Aberdeen, 2; Queen's Park, 0.
THE SECOND HALFWhen the game was resumed, there were about 8000 spectators. Aberdeen now had the sun behind them, but they had to face a slight breeze. When the ball was kicked off, the Queen's Park forwards at once bore down on the west goal. Gault cleared weakly, but Strang made "siccar." The "Spiders," however, were not to be shaken off until they had broken the defence a bit. A long, swinging pass out of Lennie lead to a race between the Queen's goalkeeper and the Aberdeen outside left. Skene got there first, and kicked the ball up the field. A minute later Skene had again to handle. Davidson and Logan, the Queen's left wing, frequently worked their way towards Macfarlane, but the raid was stopped by Davidson being given offside. Gault was again prominent for resourceful work close in. An anxious moment ensued in front of the Aberdeen goal, but ultimately Murray got the ball away, and Davidson brought relief by banging the ball skywards when he might have scored. Queen's were now pressing very hard, especially on the left; but Murray was unbeatable. Macfarlane was loudly cheered for a magnificent save. Gault was beaten by Paul, who crossed the ball in a dead line about nine feet from the goal. Quite a group of the Glasgow forwards were hovering around eager for goals. "Rab" sprang at the ball, stopped it on the ground, and, jinking his opponents kicked down the field. Strang, with blocking work, stopped a promising Queen's Park run, and he tried Skene with a high shot, which the goalkeeper returned. Edgar and Lennie gave the crowd considerable amusement by the way the tricked the defence opposed to them, and Richmond had to thank his speed for his recovery work. Aberdeen now had a spell of the pressure, and Ward just failed to get a clean parting shot. The game was being very earnestly fought out, Queen's having quite as much of the play as their opponents. The amateurs were very eager for goals, but the local backs and half-backs were too much for them. Davidson, after beating Murray, tried a shot from the touch line, and Rab gathered himself together for a spring; the ball, however, struck the side of the net. Going to the other end, Lennie ran through the Queen's defence, but, with remarkable speed, the Queen's went to the other end, and Gault, hard pressed, had to give away a corner. Davidson centred accurately, and the ball bobbed about until Macfarlane gave away a corner in endeavouring to clear his lines. Macfarlane now had a little exhibition on his own. He ran out to meet an attack, and getting the ball thirty yards out he sent it into the Gallowhill Gardens, for which feat he was ironically cheered. A minute later, however, he saved a low shot from Millar. A miskick by Gault nearly let in the Queen's forwards, but the promising young Aberdeen back recovered, and kicked into touch. In the last half-hour of the game, the Queen's Park physically superior to the Aberdeen team gradually, but nonetheless surely, wore down the Pittodrie defence. Hot and flurried, the Aberdeen half-backs and backs frequently made mistakes. Strang and Wilfred Low and Murray being specially noticeable for slackness. Forward, Lennie was as lively as ever, few passes went the way of Robertson and Ward, Edgar and Hylton were weak. Gault and Murray kicked out resolutely, but the Queen's Park pressure was so keen and well directed and disaster was sooner or later bound to the fall the Aberdeen goal. Gault was the hero of the game - he was here, there, and everywhere, showing great resource, his only weakness being reckless punting. Murray was not so effective, and seemed to be suffering from the pace. Two long shots by Houston were well saved by Macfarlane. Fair-haired and sturdy Houston was a great force in the Queen's Park attack, and he and Richmond were mainly responsible for maintaining the pressure on the Aberdeen goal. A shot from Davidson's foot struck the cross-bar. Murray's returns were weak, and were invariably picked up by Houston. At last, after many tries, the Queen's scored in a scrimmage. Gault missed his kick, and the ball going to Logan, that player shot high. Macfarlane, who was about a yard out of his goal, just failed to get his fingers on the ball, which glanced off the underside of the cross-bar into the net. Excitement now arrose to fever heat, the fierce struggle in the field being intensified by the shouting of the spectators. The Aberdeen were hopelessly hemmed in, and only occasionally broke away on a straggling run. Amidst the heat and flurry of the fray, Macfarlane remained as cool as a cucumber. Lennie on one occasion got off, closely attended by Richmond. A corner followed, but the Queen's forwards were soon of the other end. Paul, on the run, beat Gault all the way, and raced off with the ball. Macfarlane came out of his goal, and coolly awaited the onrush. Nearing Macfarlane, Paul shot on the run, and the clever Aberdeen goalkeeper coolly caught the ball in its flight over his head, and received a tremendous cheer for his brilliant save. Hard pressed, Wilfred Low gave away a corner, and a fierce scrimmage ensued in the Aberdeen goal. The players were all in a bunch - some kicking out, others kicking in. At last Davidson saw an opening, and banged the ball into the net, thus equalising the score. In the scrimmage Murray was laid out. He was injured about the head, but was able to resume. Queen's look like scoring again, but, to the relief of the Aberdeen's supporters, the whistle blew with the score - Aberdeen, 2; Queen's Park,2. The score fairly indicates the run of the play. Aberdeen claiming the honours in the first half, while the Queen's Park held the upper hand in the second half. The drawings, including stands, amounted to £192.
Source: Aberdeen Daily Journal, 26th September 1905