Source: The Scotsman, 25-08-1906
Source: Aberdeen Daily Journal, 27th August 1906
Sharp-Shooters Wanted.
The past week has clearly shown to the Aberdeen directors wherein the weakness of their team lies. On Wednesday, a clear penalty was thrown away, and again on Saturday the want of a good shot threw away points that ought to have been certain. If Henry Low and Lennie can miss this class of shots, it is time that a look should be made for one who can put the ball between the posts, even if it is saved. Why not have entrusted one of the backs with this duty? Boyle or Gault, in our opinion, would have made a better job of this than any of the forwards in their present form. The change made in the front line for Saturday did not improve the shooting of the front line by any degree of certainty, and allowing for Haxton being a little slow he knew when and where to shoot, which is more than can he said of those against the Third. On these occasions the shooting lacked directness and sting behind it, all of which points to either a weakness in their training or a lack of ball practice. To the latter we attribute the falling away, and the players ought to get this every day in the week till perfection in, at least, direction of the flight of the ball can be reached. Throwing Away Points. It has not been our lot to witness more lamentable footwork at goal-mouth at Pittodrie than that of Aberdeen's against Third Lanark. Without exaggeration the points were thrown away by bad shooting. By no stretch of imagination could one see any superiority in the Third Lanark's play iu the open, but in close quarters they made the ball skim. The fairly strong breeze did not materially assist the Third in the first period, as they had quite enough to do to keep Aberdeen in hand. Dewar had a fine shot for goal which Mutch fisted out, but not far enough to avert danger, for Munro lying handy scored. This would have been nothing had Aberdeen scored from a penalty granted against Neilson for bringing Henry Low down when well set. It would have made all the difference in the world had this been converted, but it wasn't. Another lucky chance came to the Third when the ball was driven hard against McLuckie and popped into goal just before half-time. Aberdeen pressed hard, but their efforts in front were bad, very bad. In fact, they were all trying to shoot, and everyone was a degree or so worse than his neighbour. Work hard they did for a goal, but never a one came, so the " Warriors" carried away the points.Chatty Bits.
Now's the chance for the "Letter-to-the-Editor" young man with his gratis advice as to how the Aberdeen team should be run. There is no use getting panic-struck over the day's misfortune. Other clubs are in the same boat. Surely the directors are fit to remedy the state of matters in which they find themselves so far as the team is performing. One player remarked that "if the crowd would behave better the players would give them better play." There may be something in this. It is said that the "roasting" Henry Low got on Wednesday made him refuse to take the penalty on Saturday. Tom Strang should have insisted on Henry taking the kick and the matter would have ended there. It is a matter of opinion as to Ford being a better right-winger than Robertson. .Many were to be found round the enclosure backing the latter's claims. Robertson and Ward made a better wing last season than they did on Saturday. There was an evident want of understanding between them. We will not be surprised were radical changes made in ill team for Saturday. McAuley is doing well for Falkirk, where he has made; considerable improvement in the team's play. It would appear that the Aberdeen's troubles are not t confined to the first team, for the "A" lot are not doing so well as they did last year. Hilton has got a nasty wrench, and may not be able to reins play for a week or so. Lickley kept a good goal for the "A's" on Saturday. He has now been added to Aberdeen's list. As many supporters are afraid that Mutch lacks experience, there was a cry on Saturday to get "Rab" Macfarlane back. At outside left against the Saints R. Simpson played a very fine game. Jim Robertson also did some very fine work, and bids fair to enter the first team shortly. Lickley was not to blame for the defeat, for he-saved a lot of great shots and enhanced his reputation. Geordie McNicol is likely to be seen in the Clyde ranks this week. The Shawfield management have applied for his papers. Raith Rovers will be sorry they did not come to terms with Geordie, as he would have proved a good man for them. The Scottish Rifles hold their Regimental Sports on the 14th of next month at Pittodrie. Now that Aberdeen have made no change in their team, there will be a loud outcry if they fail at Ibrox. It will be no surprise if they go down unless had plenty of shooting practice this week. The players themselves are quite aware of their weakness and have been training hard this week with a view to retrieving their reputations.Source: Bon-Accord, 30th August 1906